Rosh Hashanah orders are open at Bagel Plus  ·  Order large trays and platters by Wednesday, September 9 →
Bagel Plus · Rosh Hashanah 5787

Rosh Hashanah at Bagel Plus

Wishing you a sweet, healthy and happy New Year.

Our holiday supplementary menu is open for pre-order. Round challah, honey cake, rugelach and rolls, whitefish and lox platters, salads and full catering trays. All of it made at our North York bakery, the same way we have made it since 1979.

Pre-Order the Holiday Menu Call 416-635-9988
Large order cutoff closes in
--Days
:
--Hours
:
--Minutes
:
--Seconds
Rosh Hashanah begins sundown Friday, September 11 Large orders by Wednesday, September 9 Pickup at 634 Sheppard Ave W 416-635-9988
The Holiday
Sundown Friday, September 11 to nightfall Sunday, September 13
Order Deadline
Wednesday, September 9 for large trays and platters
Pickup
634 Sheppard Ave W, North York
How It Works

Three Steps to a Full Holiday Table

1

Choose from the menu

The full Rosh Hashanah supplementary menu is below, with prices. Challah, cakes and rolls, cookies and meringues, salads, platters and per-person catering.

2

Send your order

Use the pre-order form on this page, call 416-635-9988, or email Info@bagelplus.ca. Large trays and platters should be in by Wednesday, September 9.

3

Pick it up fresh

We confirm your pickup time by phone or email. Everything is baked and prepared for the day you collect it, not before.

Holiday Supplementary Menu

The Rosh Hashanah Menu

Available for the holiday only, alongside our everyday bagels and breads. Use the plus and minus buttons to build your order. It fills in the pre-order form for you at the bottom of the page.

Challah

  • Crown Plain20.95
  • Crown Raisin21.95
  • Small Round Plain7.50
  • Small Round Raisin7.95
  • Large Round Plain8.50
  • Large Round Raisin8.95
  • Square Challah7.49
  • Square Raisin Challah7.95

Round challah is the holiday loaf. Order the crown sizes early, they go first.

Cakes & Rolls

  • Vanilla Cake24.95
  • Chocolate Fudge Cake24.95
  • Double Dipped Cake24.95
  • Chocolate Roll16.95
  • Mocha Roll19.95
  • Double Dip Roll15.95
  • Lemon Roll15.49
  • Raspberry Roll15.49
  • Chocolate Babka12.95
  • Chocolate Ring12.95
  • Honey Cake15.99
  • Marble Cake13.99
  • Apple Cinnamon Cake13.99
  • French Cake13.99
  • Blueberry Cake13.99

Honey cake is the traditional sweet for the New Year. We bake it fresh for the holiday.

Cookies & Meringues

  • Apple Pan24.95
  • Plain Sponge12.99
  • Lemon Meringue16.50
  • Chocolate Cupcake4.25 each
  • Regular Pie13.99
  • Sugar Free Pies14.99
  • Mixed CookiesAssorted tray22.90
  • Mandel Bread22.90

Deli, Salads & Platters

Salads
  • Greek21.36
  • Spinach21.36
  • Caesar16.88
  • Gefilte Fish7.75 per piece
Fruit Platter
  • Small80.00
  • Medium125.00
  • Large160.00
Cookie Platter
  • Small65.00
  • Medium80.00
  • Large95.00
Per Person
  • Tuna, Egg & Cream Cheese PlatterWith vegetables and bagels14.99
  • Tuna, Egg, Cream Cheese & Lox PlatterWith vegetables and bagels19.99
  • Smoked WhitefishAdd to any platteradd 5.99

Platters and per-person catering need the most notice. Get these in by Wednesday, September 9.

Your Order

Nothing selected yet

Pick quantities from the menu above and they will appear here, with a running estimate.

    $0.00 Estimate before tax. We confirm the final total when we call you back.
    Continue to Pre-Order →

    Prices in CAD and subject to change. Questions on quantities, call 416-635-9988.

    Why Bagel Plus

    On the North York Holiday Table Since 1979

    Bagel Plus has baked for this neighbourhood's holidays for over 40 years. Hand-rolled. No preservatives, no additives, never frozen.

    The Rosh Hashanah menu is the same standard, scaled for a full table. Round challah, honey cake, platters and trays, prepared for the day you pick them up.

    1979
    Founded in Toronto
    40+
    Years in the community
    100%
    Hand-rolled dough
    #1
    Bagel in North York

    Rolling Since 1979

    Every Bagel Plus bagel and loaf starts the same way it always has. Hand-shaped, baked to a golden crust, out the door the day you buy it. No preservatives, no additives, never frozen. Shanah tovah from all of us on Sheppard Ave.

    Place Your Order

    Order Early to Ensure Availability

    Holiday baking runs on a fixed schedule. Large trays, platters and per-person catering should be confirmed by Wednesday, September 9. Later orders will be accommodated where we can.

    Call the bakery
    416-635-9988
    Email your order
    Info@bagelplus.ca
    Use the Pre-Order Form →

    Bagel Plus · 634 Sheppard Ave W, North York ON · Open 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM

    0 items $0.00 estimate
    Review & Send
    Rosh Hashanah Pre-Order

    Send Us Your Order

    Your picks from the menu above are already in the order box. Add anything else you need, then send it. We confirm the final total and your pickup time by phone or email. If it is easier, call the bakery directly at 416-635-9988.

    • Wednesday, September 9 for large orders Platters, trays and per-person catering need the most lead time. Smaller bakery orders we will fit in where we can.
    • Pickup at 634 Sheppard Ave W Open 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM. We will confirm a pickup window with you once the order is in.
    • Baked for the day you collect it Hand-rolled, no preservatives, no additives, never frozen. The same standard as every other day of the year.

    Prefer to email? Send your list to Info@bagelplus.ca


      Find Us

      634 Sheppard Ave W, North York

      Open 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM. Call 416-635-9988 to confirm holiday hours before you come for pickup.

      Feeding More Than One Table This Year?

      Bagel Plus catering starts at $200 and serves 15 to 200+ guests. Full schmear bar, lox platters, salads and same-day delivery across the GTA. Break-fast, office lunches and family gatherings alike.

      Rosh Hashanah Menu

      Round challah, honey cake, platters and catering trays.

      Order large trays and platters by Wednesday, September 9.

       
       

      Order Online 

      We deliver via Uber Eats.

      Check out our online menu!

      Bakery & Food Service Daily 7:00 am to 6.00 pm

       
       
      7-9am In-Restaurant 25% Off Entire Breakfast Menu Everyday!

      The BP Breakfast Club 

      More Information Here